Freedom of choice in education at all levels would improve the lives of all children and their parents. A total voucher system for educational choices would help to achieve free choice in education for most people. Obviously, any voucher system would require some type of regulation to insure that teachers receive good compensation and that all types of students receive an acceptable education. Additional funding per voucher would be needed for special education students and students on an IEP. Competition for voucher dollars should have a positive effect on the service provided by schools to students and parents. Religious schools would be able to equally financially compete with state schools which would increase diversity of thought and quality of education in my opinion.
Many European nations have given full or partial government payments to various types of private schools chosen by parents so a total voucher system in the USA would not be that unique. South Korea and Australia also have some programs of this nature. These countries are first world industrial class nations so maybe they might have a good idea or two we could copy and improve upon.
I suspect that a full voucher system would eventually cause a heavy increase in attendance at religious schools and a decrease in attendance at state schools because parents want children to develop good values. This potential shift away from state schools scares many state educators today because they would lose students and the money associated with them attending a state school. These state educators are probably right to be concerned because it directly affects their jobs. Some state schools may not be able to compete in a voucher system because parents don’t want to send their children to a school that may be perceived as less than some type of private school.
I remember when one of my children needed some specific services that could only be provided by a particular private school. The public school officials didn’t want to pay for this service from the private school and they fought us every step of the way until it became painfully obvious things just were not working for our child at that public school. No one likes to admit that they can’t do something especially when money is involved and it might set a precedent for others to follow. This experience diminished my sympathy for the administrators of public schools but not all public schools may have this type of situation. The school district did finally agree to pay for the services from the private school.
I remember my first class in college called Engineering 101. Our first assignment was an individual oral presentation to the class and an associated paper. I was shocked when one of the students started giving his oral presentation because you could clearly tell his large public school system from another state had let him down by the manner in which he was speaking. I don’t think he had any disability other than that no teacher had ever forced him to speak coherently. After speaking, he ripped his paper from a spiral wire notebook and attempted to hand it to the professor. The professor didn’t accept the handwritten report and asked to see him after class.
I never saw the other student again even though MSOE is not that big. He must have been able to qualify to get into college by having good grades, good test scores and enough money to pay tuition. MSOE gets a lot of foreign students from non-English speaking countries but he was from America. I felt sad for this person because he had made such an effort to be there and was really being defeated by a prior educational system experience that had not prepared him adequately for simple things. I suspect that if this person had received the same opportunity that I had growing up attending good schools he would have had no problem.
The best student I ever met at MSOE was a Vietnamese girl with a 4.0 grade point average. She had good grades in spite of English not being her native language. She was certainly smart but the real reason she had good grades seemed to be that she just worked harder than anyone I had ever met previously. I suspect her family taught her that trait and reinforced it during her prior education. Parents should have the ability to choose the education their children get although I think her parents did an exceptional job under difficult circumstances.
Isn’t the freedom to choose what America is really all about? Vouchers would allow less wealthy families to have a choice to send their child where they want. Why would anyone be opposed to free choice?






